Preaching to Personas (why you can’t preach to everyone)

by | Church Communication, Leadership

Jesus, in His earthly ministry, couldn’t preach to everyone; so, He practiced preaching to personas. He knew His local audience! And then, what He said reached a greater audience. 

Can you preach to everyone? No. You need to know your local audience, get their attention, and then preach God’s Word. And thanks to digital tools, you’ll reach a greater audience as God’s Word has a way to exceed expectations!

What are Personas? A stereotypical description of a particular audience segment.

Note: Knowing your audience personas doesn’t mean watering down scripture or changing the Biblical message. Rather, it’s about creating content that’ll be heard. Preaching to personas is a scriptural principle and an effective way to impart Godly wisdom to a World who’s mostly stopped listening to the Church.

Trying to preach to everyone? Impossible. Instead, preach to most. Here are the 4 steps:

  1. Identify and fall in love with the majority. This can be difficult without research. With any audience, it’s tempting to speak from your heart and hope that it speaks to theirs. A better way? Consider a stereotypical description of the majority of your audience and concentrate on their needs, concerns, and goals. Most groups are more similar than dissimilar since “birds of a feather” do like to “flock together”. But God doesn’t call us to just know our audiences, He commands us to love them! Meaning, do whatever it takes to understand them: listening to them and researching them! Then love them by offering Biblical solutions to their pains and paths to help them achieve goals.
  2. Say their name. Want to get a group’s attention? Call them by a name that they’ll recognize. Repeat it regularly to bring them back when their minds drift. A name can be a persona description (e.g. husbands, wives, young married couples, etc.) or a name that describes pains (e.g. Are you lonely? Trying to get ahead?). Trying to talk to everyone will not get their attention (e.g. Beloved, Church, etc.). 
  3. Speak their pain. After hearing their name, an audience will look up. In that small engagement, you need to speak about their needs or concerns. Or a goal they’ve attempted to achieve but something’s standing in their way. The more you can associate as their pain expert, the more people will trust you. Tell stories of how you authentically connect with their pain to prolong their attention span. It’ll empathetically connect you to their hearts and minds. Preaching to personas lets them know you’ve done the research and you care about them. 
  4. Solutions from the Bible to proclaim. Finally, after saying their name and speaking about their pain, you can get them to lean in to your message if you continue with, “but God’s Word has been my guide to the solution. Want to hear it?” Make the Bible your guide and then become their Biblical guide to help them discover and practice solutions. Then post your sermon online with search keywords of your audience, pain, and solution; and a greater audience (similar to your persona) will discover it!

Mark MacDonald is communication pastor, speaker, consultant, bestselling author, church branding strategist for BeKnownforSomething.com and Executive Director of Center for Church Communication, empowering 10,000+ churches to become known for something relevant (a communication thread) throughout their ministries, websites, & social media. His book, Be Known for Something, is available at BeKnownBook.com. 

Sign Up for the Worship Facility Newsletter!

NEW THIS WEEK

Worship Facility Podcast: Leadership and Tech Teams

David Leuschner talks to Nicole Lucas, author of "Leadership Frameworks" about how leadership skills, social skills, and emotional intelligence apply to leading a tech team.Other topics include: What to do with your used production gear What churches need to do to...

Intro to House of Worship Production with Vectorworks

As houses of worship embrace modern technology to enhance their services, the demand for production tools is increasing.  This article covers, first, what’s meant by “house of worship production” and “church production,” and then explores how Vectorworks can...

Green Hippo Previews Hippotizer MX Series at LDI 2024

Green Hippo, an industry leader in media manipulation and 3D mapping, was thrilled to preview its new Hippotizer MX Series with ACT Entertainment at Live Design International 2024. The Hippotizer MX Series offers five new customizable, dependable, and future-proofed...

Deadly Shooting at Abundant Life Christian School in Wisconsin

How Should Christian Schools Respond to the Threat of Gun Violence? Only three weeks ago, I was sitting in the head of school's office at a private Christian school in Minnesota discussing gun violence and their response to such a threat. There were three real options...

7 Key Security Trends Churches Should Prioritize in 2025

As we step into 2025, church safety and security leaders face an ever-evolving landscape of challenges and opportunities. From technological advancements to addressing the rising tensions in society, this year brings a renewed focus on critical areas of improvement....